Research Article
Level Of Healthcare Providers Practice and Factor Associated with Preconception Care in Ilu Aba Bora Zone Health Facility
- Alemayehu Desale *
Midwifery department, public health and medical sciences, Mettu University, Mettu, Ethiopia.
*Corresponding Author: Alemayehu Desale, Midwifery department, public health and medical sciences, Mettu University, Mettu, Ethiopia.
Citation: Desale. A. (2024). Level Of Healthcare Providers Practice and Factor Associated with Preconception Care in Ilu Aba Bora Zone Health Facility. Journal of BioMed Research and Reports, BioRes Scientia Publishers. 5(5):1-12. DOI: 10.59657/2837-4681.brs.24.111
Copyright: © 2024 Alemayehu Desale, this is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Received: September 09, 2024 | Accepted: October 01, 2024 | Published: November 10, 2024
Abstract
Introduction: Preconception health refers to the health of all individuals during their reproductive years, regardless of gender identity, gender expression or sexual orientation. It is an approach that promotes healthy fertility and focuses on actions that individuals can take to reduce risks, promote healthy lifestyles, and increase readiness for pregnancy, whether or not they plan to have children one day. The objectives of this study were assessing the level of healthcare providers practice preconception care and factor associated with preconception care in Ilubabor zone health facility.
Methods: A facility based cross sectional study was conducted on 442 healthcare providers. The sample size was determined by using a single population proportion formula. Multistage sampling technique was used to select the study units. Bivariate and multivariable logistic regression was done to describe association among variables.
Result: Four hundred twenty-two health care providers were involved with 95% response rate. From total participants, 301(71.3%) participants were female and 121(28.7%) were male. Two hundred thirty-six (55.9%) participants had good knowledge about preconception care and one hundred thirty-two (31.3%) had practiced Preconception care. From binary analysis practicing preconception care significantly associated with healthcare provider knowledge about PCC, profession (midwifery and nurse), their experience (2-5 years), educational status (both diploma and degree level) and with practice setting at p-value < 0.05 and 95% CI. Multivariate logistic regression analysis of those independent variables with p-value < 0.05 showed healthcare provider knowledge about Preconception care, being midwifery and nurse in profession and practicing in health center and health post had significant association with preconception care practice.
Conclusion: More than half of health care providers had knowledge about the preconception care but their preconception care practice level was still low. This initiates stakeholders to work on creating awareness and increasing willingness of health care providers to provide preconception care.
Keywords: preconception care; fetal alcoholic syndrome; obesity; teratogen; contraception; infertility
Introduction
Preconception health refers to the health of all individuals during their reproductive years, regardless of gender identity, gender expression or sexual orientation. It is an approach that promotes healthy fertility and focuses on actions that individuals can take to reduce risks, promote healthy lifestyles, and increase readiness for pregnancy, whether or not they plan to have children one day [1]. Many of the maternal and paternal risk factors for poor birth outcomes, such as lifestyle behaviors, are modifiable in the preconception period [2]. In fact, research has shown that PCH has positive impacts on many reproductive health outcomes and is cost effective for specific interventions, such as folic acid supplementation and diabetes care [3]. While it is not an exhaustive list, PCH can prevent preterm births; improve birth weight; prevent congenital anomalies, including neural tube defects; reduce infant mortality; reduce maternal mortality [4]. Twelve evidence-based preconception intervention categories were highlighted for women of reproductive age: Eat a well-balanced diet, reduce stress, Exercise regularly, manage chronic medical conditions, cease smoking, Identify and treat women at risk of severe morning sickness, avoid alcohol intake, maintain a healthy weight, cease illicit drug use, take multivitamins with folic acid, reduce environmental toxin exposure and get vaccinated [1]. While this update addresses a number of PCH interventions, some opportune interventions are lacking, notably screening, treatment and prevention of STIs, including HIV/AIDS in individual and sexual partners [5]; planning and prevention of unintended pregnancies [6]; promotion of optimal birth spacing [6]; and utilization of contact with an individual to provide health education [7]. Alberta has been the only province to date to develop a PCH agenda, releasing their ‘Preconception Health Framework’ in 2007 [8]. The framework identifies that “despite advances in medical science, universal access to health services and high-quality prenatal care, rates of adverse perinatal outcomes persist and some problems are increasing” [8]. With this in mind, the document sets out a preconception health framework with three key strategies as an avenue to impact this concern: Promote Public Awareness and Knowledge, Build Capacity to Provide PCH Services and Champion PCH Supporting Environments [8]. Healthy birth outcomes contribute to the foundation for healthy children and families [9]. Conversely, poor birth outcomes have the potential to create detrimental lifelong growth and developmental outcomes for children and can also lead to higher costs and strains on families and society [9]. For example, the estimated average neonatal hospital costs for babies less than 2,500g (low birth weight) in Canada ranges from $4,600.00 - $117,800.00, compared to $950.00 for the cost of a baby who weighs more than 2,500g [10]. Traditionally, reproductive health programming in public health has focused on prenatal and postpartum services, such as in-class and online prenatal classes, the Canada Prenatal Nutrition Program (CPNP), and the Healthy Babies Healthy Children (HBHC) Program. Despite such programming, advances in medical science and quality prenatal care, poor birth outcomes continue to be a national and provincial concern [8]. Adverse perinatal outcomes, such as moderate and late preterm births (32 to <37>
Demonstrating the cost effectiveness of PCH is an important part of making the case for public health investment. Like many other areas of public health, there is limited economic evaluation of PCH care [3]. There have been analyses showing the financial benefits of specific preconception care interventions, such as folic acid supplementation [15]. Thus, this study was aimed to assess the level of healthcare providers practice preconception care and factor associated with preconception care in Ilubabor zone health facility.
Introduction
Preconception health refers to the health of all individuals during their reproductive years, regardless of gender identity, gender expression or sexual orientation. It is an approach that promotes healthy fertility and focuses on actions that individuals can take to reduce risks, promote healthy lifestyles, and increase readiness for pregnancy, whether or not they plan to have children one day [1]. Many of the maternal and paternal risk factors for poor birth outcomes, such as lifestyle behaviors, are modifiable in the preconception period [2]. In fact, research has shown that PCH has positive impacts on many reproductive health outcomes and is cost effective for specific interventions, such as folic acid supplementation and diabetes care [3]. While it is not an exhaustive list, PCH can prevent preterm births; improve birth weight; prevent congenital anomalies, including neural tube defects; reduce infant mortality; reduce maternal mortality [4]. Twelve evidence-based preconception intervention categories were highlighted for women of reproductive age: Eat a well-balanced diet, reduce stress, Exercise regularly, manage chronic medical conditions, cease smoking, Identify and treat women at risk of severe morning sickness, avoid alcohol intake, maintain a healthy weight, cease illicit drug use, take multivitamins with folic acid, reduce environmental toxin exposure and get vaccinated [1]. While this update addresses a number of PCH interventions, some opportune interventions are lacking, notably screening, treatment and prevention of STIs, including HIV/AIDS in individual and sexual partners [5]; planning and prevention of unintended pregnancies [6]; promotion of optimal birth spacing [6]; and utilization of contact with an individual to provide health education [7]. Alberta has been the only province to date to develop a PCH agenda, releasing their ‘Preconception Health Framework’ in 2007 [8]. The framework identifies that “despite advances in medical science, universal access to health services and high-quality prenatal care, rates of adverse perinatal outcomes persist and some problems are increasing” [8]. With this in mind, the document sets out a preconception health framework with three key strategies as an avenue to impact this concern: Promote Public Awareness and Knowledge, Build Capacity to Provide PCH Services and Champion PCH Supporting Environments [8]. Healthy birth outcomes contribute to the foundation for healthy children and families [9]. Conversely, poor birth outcomes have the potential to create detrimental lifelong growth and developmental outcomes for children and can also lead to higher costs and strains on families and society [9]. For example, the estimated average neonatal hospital costs for babies less than 2,500g (low birth weight) in Canada ranges from $4,600.00 - $117,800.00, compared to $950.00 for the cost of a baby who weighs more than 2,500g [10]. Traditionally, reproductive health programming in public health has focused on prenatal and postpartum services, such as in-class and online prenatal classes, the Canada Prenatal Nutrition Program (CPNP), and the Healthy Babies Healthy Children (HBHC) Program. Despite such programming, advances in medical science and quality prenatal care, poor birth outcomes continue to be a national and provincial concern [8]. Adverse perinatal outcomes, such as moderate and late preterm births (32 to <37>
Demonstrating the cost effectiveness of PCH is an important part of making the case for public health investment. Like many other areas of public health, there is limited economic evaluation of PCH care [3]. There have been analyses showing the financial benefits of specific preconception care interventions, such as folic acid supplementation [15]. Thus, this study was aimed to assess the level of healthcare providers practice preconception care and factor associated with preconception care in Ilubabor zone health facility.
Methods
Study design and Area
A facility based cross sectional study was conducted at Ilubabor Zone in the south western Ethiopia from September 1 to 30 August, 2018 and its capital city is Metu which is located 600km from Addis Ababa.
Study units
All selected GP, Midwifery, nurses, health officers and HEWs working in the selected health facility.
Sample Size and Sampling techniques
The sample size was determined by using a single population proportion formula with level of healthcare providers practice which was 15.5%, taken from study conducted in Hawassa, south Ethiopia (27), Level of significance to be 5% (α = 0.05), Z α/2= 1.96 and, Absolute precision or margin of error to be 5% (d = 0.05), and adding 10% of non-response rate, the total sample size was=442.Multistage sampling technique was used to select the study units. One primary hospital and twenty health centers was selected at primary sampling stages, from each health facility general practitioner, midwifery, nurses and health extension worker was selected at secondary sampling stages. Then sample size was proportionally allocated for selected health care providers and study participants were selected by simple random sampling technique.
Variables of the study
Dependent /Outcome variable
Preconception practice care
Independent variables
Socio-cultural variables (age, marital status, educational status, experiences, facility, religion) Preconception care components: Eat a well-balanced diet, reduce stress, Exercise regularly, manage chronic medical conditions, cease smoking, Identify and treat women at risk of severe morning sickness, avoid alcohol intake, maintain a healthy weight, cease illicit drug use, take multivitamins with folic acid, reduce environmental toxin exposure and get vaccinated
Inclusion and Exclusion criteria
Inclusion criteria
All general practitioner, midwife, nurse, and health extension worker who have been working in selected facility >6month were included and health professional workers such as Pharmacy, laboratory, radiologist, and severely ill health care providers.
Data collection tools and procedures
Data was collected through pre-tested structured interview that adapted from study conducted in Ethiopia. The questionnaire was translated from English into Afan Oromo and back to English by language experts to check for consistency. The questionnaire consists of socio-demographic characteristics of respondents, knowledge of preconception care and practice of preconception care. Sixteen Health extension workers were used to collect data from January 10 to August 30 2019. Four midwives from each town of Health Center will be assigned to supervise the data collection process.
Both the data collectors and supervisors were given two days intensive training before the actual work about the aim of study, procedures, and data collection techniques going through the questionnaires question by question, art of interviewing, ways of collecting the data and clarification will be given.
Data Processing and Analysis
All the questionnaire was checked visually, coded and entered SPSS 20 software packages for analysis. The data was analyzed using bivariate regression to determine the relationship between factors and the outcome variable at p-value less than 0.25.and multivariate regression also used to compare the relationships of those significantly associated with the outcome variable. The results would present in the form of tables, figures and text using frequencies and percentage to describe the study population in relation to relevant variables. The degree of association between independent and dependent variables was assessed using odds ratio with 95% confidence interval.
Data Quality control
The quality of data was assured by proper designing and pre-testing of the questionnaires in one of the health facility other than the selected facility on 10% of participants, and by giving training for the data collectors and supervisors before the actual data collection. Every day after data collection, questionnaires was reviewed and checked for completeness and relevance by the supervisors and principal investigator and the necessary feedback was offered to data collectors in the next morning.
Results
Sociodemographic Characteristics
Four hundred twenty-two health care providers were involved in study with 95% response rate. From total participants 301(71.3%) participants were female and 121(28.7%) were male. One hundred eighty-eight (44.5%) participants were within 20-24 yrs., one hundred ninety-nine (47.2%) were 25-29yrs, thirty-two (7.6%) were 30-34 and three (.7%) were 40-45 yrs old. Three hundred twenty-four (76.8%) were married, ninety-six (22.7%) were single and two (.5%) were divorced. From total participants 164(38.9%) were Muslim, 152(36%) were protestant, 104(24.6%) were orthodox and 2(.5%) were Catholics. Professionally 206(48.8%) participants were HE, 131(31.0%) were nurse, 55(13%) were midwifery and 30(7.1%) were HO. One hundred sixty-six (39.3%) of participants had 2-5 yrs experiences, one hundred thirty-nine (32.9%) had 10-14 yrs and one hundred seventeen (27.7%) had 6-9 yrs work experiences. From total participants 337(79.9%) were diploma and 85(20.1%) degree in their educational levels. Two hundred twelve (50.2%) works in HC, one hundred sixty-one (38.2%) in HP and forty-nine (11.6%) in hospitals (Table 1).
Table 1: sociodemographic characteristics of participants (n = 422)
Variables | Frequency | Percent |
Sex | ||
Female | 301 | 71.3 |
Male | 121 | 28.7 |
Age | ||
20-24 | 188 | 44.5 |
25-29 | 199 | 42.7 |
30-34 | 32 | 7.6 |
40-45 | 3 | 0.7 |
Marital status | ||
Single | 96 | 22.7 |
Married | 324 | 76.8 |
Divorced | 2 | 0.5 |
Religion | ||
Orthodox | 104 | 24.6 |
Protestant | 152 | 36 |
Muslim | 164 | 38.9 |
Catholic | 2 | 0.5 |
Profession | ||
General practitioners | 30 | 7.1 |
Midwifery | 55 | 13 |
Nurse | 131 | 31 |
Health extension | 206 | 48.8 |
Educational status | ||
Diploma | 79.9 | |
Degree | 337 | 20.1 |
85 | ||
Work experience | ||
2-5 years | 166 | 39.3 |
6-9 years | 117 | 27.7 |
10-14 years | 139 | 32.9 |
Work place | ||
Health center | 212 | 50.2 |
Hospital | 49 | 11.6 |
Health post | 161 | 38.2 |
Participants knowledge of PCC
From total 422 participants 236(55.9%) had good knowledge of Preconception care. For each question of preconception care knowledge three hundred eighty eight (91.9%) knew all adolescent and reproductive aged group were eligible for Preconception care; seventy seven (18.2%) knew preconception care didn’t start four weeks before conception; three hundred twenty (75.8%) knew periodontal disease is risk factor for Adverse Pregnancy Outcome; three hundred seven (72.7%) knew women with BMI less/equal 18.4 at risk for APO; three hundred thirty (78.2%) knew all women of reproductive age should take 0.4mg folic acid daily; two hundred eighty eight (67.8%) knew recommended preconception laboratory test include hgb, hct, HIV, Hbv and RPR or VDRL tests; three hundred twenty four (76.8%) knew preconception genetic counseling and screening includes recommending carrier screening test for client with sickle cell haemoglobinopathies; one hundred fourteen (27%) knew clinician providing preconception care for client with diabetes mellitus and chronic hypertension should not recommend genetic screening test; one hundred eighty two (43.1%) health care providers knew isoretinion, valproic acid and warfarin poses teratogenic effect requires preconception modification; one hundred fourteen (27%) knew women with asthma planning pregnancy should not avoid taking salbutamol one month before and after conception; three hundred fifteen (74.6%) knew early identification and treatment of depression, seizure and phenylketonuria during preconception period reduce the occurrence of APO; three hundred twenty (75.8%) knew recommended test that guarantee good preconception blood sugar control for women with pregestational diabetes is RBS test; one hundred thirty one (31%) knew all vaccine including influenza vaccine, vaccine such as HPV, rubella and varicella are all vaccine contraindicated during pregnancy; two hundred fifty nine (61.4%) knew women planning pregnancy should aim 30 minute of moderate exercise 5 days a week; three hundred seven (72.7%) knew women planning pregnancy should be advised to delay pregnancy until reducing drug, alcohol and tobacco use; two hundred sixty seven (63.3%) knew avoiding exposure to environmental hazard or toxins such as ionizing radiation, pesticides, lead, mercury and pets is a concern for women with established first trimester pregnancy; not for couples planning pregnancy; two hundred eighty five (67.5%) knew clinician attending client with previous CS should advice the client to delay the next pregnancy for at least 18 month before next conception and one hundred twenty nine (35.3%) health care providers knew infertility screening and managements is the concern of preconception care(Table 2).
Table 2: participants knowledge of preconception care (n=422)
Variable | Frequency | Percent |
Overall knowledge of preconception care among participant | ||
Good knowledge | 236 | 55.9 |
Poor knowledge | 186 | 44.1 |
All adolescent and reproductive aged group eligible for PCC | ||
TRUE | 388 | 91.9 |
FALSE | 34 | 8.1 |
To be effective preconception care should start four weeks before conception | ||
True | 320 | 75.8 |
False | 102 | 24.1 |
Periodontal disease is risk factor for Adverse pregnancy outcome | ||
True | 320 | 75.8 |
False | 102 | 24.1 |
Women with BMI less/equal 18.4 at risk for APO | ||
TRUE | 307 | 72.7 |
FALSE | 115 | 27.3 |
All women of reproductive age should take 0.4mg folic acid daily | ||
TRUE | 330 | 78.2 |
FALSE | 92 | 21.8 |
Recommended preconception lab test includes Hgb, hct, HIV, HBv and RPR or VDRL | ||
TRUE | ||
FALSE | 286 | 67.8 |
136 | 25.8 | |
Preconception genetic counseling and screening include recommending carrier screening test for client with sickle cell heamoglobinopathies | ||
TRUE | 324 | 76.8 |
FALSE | 98 | 23.2 |
Clinician providing PCC for client with diabetes mellitus and chronic hypertension should recommend genetic screening test | ||
TRUE | 292 | 69.2 |
FALSE | 130 | 30.8 |
Isoretinion, valproic acid and warfarin poses teratogenic effect requires preconception modification | ||
TRUE | 182 | 43.1 |
FALSE | 240 | 46.9 |
Women with asthma planning pregnancy should avoid taking salbutamol one month before and after conception | ||
TRUE | 264 | 62.6 |
FALSE | 158 | 37.4 |
Early identification and treatment of depression, seizure and phenylketonuria during preconception period reduce the occurrence of APO | ||
TRUE | 315 | 74.6 |
FALSE | 107 | 25.3 |
Recommended test that guarantees good preconception blood sugar control for a woman with pre-gestational diabetes is RBS test | ||
TRUE | 320 | 75.8 |
FALSE | 102 | 24.2 |
Except influenza vaccine, vaccine such as HPV, rubella and varicella are all vaccine contraindicated during pregnancy | ||
TRUE | ||
FALSE | 266 | 63 |
156 | 37 | |
Women planning pregnancy should aim 30 minute of moderate exercise 5 days a week | ||
TRUE | 259 | 61.4 |
FALSE | 163 | 38.6 |
Women planning pregnancy should be advised to delay pregnancy until reducing drug, alcohol and tobacco use | ||
TRUE | 307 | 72.7 |
FALSE | 115 | 7.3 |
Avoiding exposure to environmental hazard or toxins such as ionizing radiation, pesticides, lead, mercury and pets is a concern for women with established first trimester pregnancy not for couple planning pregnancy | ||
TRUE | 267 | 63.3 |
FALSE | 155 | 36.7 |
Clinician attending client with previous CS should advice the client to delay the next pregnancy for at least 18 months before next conception | ||
TRUE | 285 | 67.5 |
FALSE | 137 | 32.5 |
Infertility screening and management is not the concern of preconception care | ||
TRUE | 273 | 64.7 |
FALSE | 149 | 35.3 |
Practice Of Preconception Care
Form total 422 participants 132(31.3%) had practiced Preconception care. Two hundred thirty nine (56.6%) of participants always counsel on FP method, one hundred twelve (26.5%) never counsel on FP method and seventy one (16.8%) sometimes counsel on FP method; Two hundred eleven (50%) always counsel on pregnancy planning, one hundred twenty eight (30.3%) never counsel on pregnancy planning and eighty three (19.7%) sometimes counsel on pregnancy planning; one hundred fifty six (37%) always counsel on regular exercise, one hundred thirty two (31.3%) never counsel on regular exercise and one hundred thirty four (31.8%) sometimes counsel on regular exercise; one hundred eighty four (43.6%) always counsel on body weight, one hundred twenty eight (30.3%) never counsel on body weight and one hundred ten (26.1%) sometimes counsel on body weight. Two hundred thirteen (50.4%) always counsel on alcohol, tobacco and psychoactive substance use, one hundred sixteen (27.5%) never counsel on alcohol, tobacco and psychoactive substance use, and ninety-three (22%) sometimes counsel on alcohol, tobacco and psychoactive substance use.
One hundred sixty (37.9%) always counsel on multivitamin containing folic acid, one hundred sixty-two (38.4%) never counsel on multivitamin containing folic acid and one hundred (23.7%) sometimes counsel on multivitamin containing folic acid. One hundred thirty-five (32%) always counsel on the importance of maintaining good control of preexisting medical condition before conception, two hundred sixteen (51.2%) never counsel on the importance of maintaining good control of preexisting medical condition before conception and seventy-one (16.8%) sometimes counsel on the importance of maintaining good control of preexisting medical condition before conception. One hundred forty-nine (35.3%) always counsel on importance of screening for STI/HIV, one hundred ninety (45%) never counsel on importance of screening for STI/HIV and eighty-three (19.7%) sometimes counsel importance of screening for STI/HIV. One hundred thirty (30.8%) always counsel on the dangers of prescribed and nonprescribed medication use, one hundred eighty-eight (44.5%) never counsel on the dangers of prescribed and nonprescribed medication use and one hundred four (24.6%) sometimes counsel the dangers of prescribed and nonprescribed medication use. One hundred forty-six (34.6%) always counsel on environmental hazard and toxin, one hundred seventy-eight (42.2%) never counsel on environmental hazard and toxin and ninety-eight (23.2%) sometimes counsel on environmental hazard and toxin. One hundred fifty-nine (37.7%) always counsel on preventive vaccine, one hundred ninety-two (45.5%) never counsel on preventive vaccine and seventy-one (16.8%) sometimes counsel on preventive vaccine. One hundred sixty-two (38.4%) always counsel on the importance of inviting partner for pc counseling, risk screening and management, 188(44.5%) never practice counseling the importance of inviting partner for pc counseling, risk screening and management and seventy-two (17.1%) sometimes counsel on the importance of inviting partner for pc counseling, risk screening and mgt. One hundred fifty (35.5%) always practice intervention related to folic acid supplementation, one hundred ninety-three (45.7%) never practice intervention related to folic acid supplementation and seventy-nine (18.7%) sometimes practice intervention related to folic acid supplementation. One hundred sixty-two (38.4%) always practice intervention related to substance use cessation e.g alcohol, cigarette or other drugs, one hundred seventy-two (40.8%) never practice intervention related to substance use cessation, e.g alcohol, cigarette or other drugs and eighty-eight (20.9%) sometimes practice intervention related to substance use cessation, e.g alcohol, cigarette or other drugs. One hundred fourteen (27%) always practice intervention related to selecting safe medication or substituting the existing with safe one, one hundred eighty-seven (44.3%) never practice intervention related to selecting safe medication or substituting the existing with safe one and one hundred twenty-one (28.7%) sometimes practice intervention related to selecting safe medication or substituting the existing with safe one. One hundred thirteen (26.8%) always practice intervention related to ordering routine preconception laboratory investigation, one hundred eighty-one (42.9%) never practice intervention related to ordering routine preconception laboratory investigation and one hundred twenty-eight (30.3%) sometimes practice intervention related to ordering routine preconception laboratory investigation. One hundred thirty eight (32.7%) always practice intervention related to diagnosing and managing of acute or chronic preconception risk condition, one hundred eighty seven (44.3%) never practice intervention related to diagnosing and managing of acute or chronic preconception risk condition and ninety seven (23%) sometimes practice intervention related to diagnosing and managing of acute or chronic preconception risk condition .One hundred thirty nine (32.9%) always practice intervention related to controlling existing pregestational chronic disease, one hundred eighty one (42.9%) never practice intervention related to controlling existing pregestational chronic disease and one hundred two (24.2%) sometimes practice intervention related to controlling existing pregestational chronic disease. One hundred sixty-one (38.1%) always practice intervention related to vaccination of clients as per the national protocol, one hundred sixty-six (39.3%) never practice intervention related to vaccination of clients as per the national protocol and ninety-five (22.5%) sometimes practice intervention related to vaccination of clients as per the national protocol. One hundred fifty-six (37%) always practice intervention related to pregnancy confirmation, one hundred fifty-three (36.3%) never practice intervention related to pregnancy confirmation and one hundred thirteen (26.8%) sometimes practice intervention related to pregnancy confirmation. One hundred eighty-four (43.6%) always practice intervention related to linking client to other relevant dept. or organization, one hundred forty-three (33.9%) never practice intervention related to linking client to other dept. or organization and ninety-five (22.5%) sometimes practice intervention related to linking client to other dept. or organization. One hundred seventy-one (40.6%) always practice intervention related to provider-initiated HIV testing counseling, one hundred fifty-six (37%) never practice intervention related to provider-initiated HIV testing counseling and ninety-five (22.5%) sometimes practice intervention related to provider-initiated HIV testing counseling (Table 3).
Table 3: Level of preconception care practice of participants (n=422)
Variables | Frequency | Percent |
Overall preconception cares practical status of participant | ||
Practiced | 132 | 31.3 |
Not practiced | 290 | 68.7 |
Counseling on Family planning method | 239 | 56.6 |
Always | 112 | 26.5 |
Never | 71 | 16.8 |
Sometimes | ||
Counseling on pregnancy planning | ||
Always | 211 | 50 |
Never | 128 | 30.3 |
Sometimes | 83 | 19.7 |
Counseling on regular exercise | ||
Always | 156 | 37 |
Never | 132 | 31.3 |
Sometimes | 134 | 31.8 |
Counseling on body weight | ||
Always | 184 | 43.6 |
Never | 128 | 30.3 |
Sometimes | 110 | 26.1 |
Counseling on alcohol, tobacco, and psychoactive substance use | ||
Always | 213 | 50.4 |
Never | 116 | 27.5 |
Sometimes | 93 | 22 |
Counseling on multivitamin containing folic acid | ||
Always | 160 | 37.9 |
Never | 162 | 38.4 |
Sometimes | 100 | 23.7 |
Counseling on the importance of maintaining good control of any preexisting medical condition before conception | ||
Always | 135 | 32 |
Never | 216 | 51.2 |
Sometimes | 71 | 16.8 |
Counseling on the importance of screening for STI/HIV | ||
Always | 149 | 35.3 |
Never | 190 | 45 |
Sometimes | 83 | 19.7 |
Counseling on the dangers of prescribed and nonprescribed medication use | ||
Always | 130 | 30.8 |
Never | 188 | 44.5 |
Sometimes | 104 | 24.6 |
Counseling on environmental hazard and toxin | ||
Always | 146 | 34.6 |
Never | 178 | 42.2 |
Sometimes | 98 | 23.2 |
Counseling on preventive vaccine | ||
Always | 159 | 37.7 |
Never | 192 | 45.5 |
Sometimes | 71 | 16.8 |
Counseling on the importance of inviting partner for preconception counseling, risk screening and management | ||
Always | 162 | 38.4 |
Never | 188 | 44.5 |
Sometimes | 72 | 17.1 |
Practice intervention related to folic acid supplementation | ||
Always | 150 | 35.5 |
Never | 193 | 45.7 |
Sometimes | 79 | 18.7 |
Practice intervention related to substance use cessation, e.g. alcohol, cigarette or other drugs | ||
Always | 162 | 38.4 |
Never | 172 | 40.8 |
Sometimes | 88 | 20.9 |
Practice intervention related to selecting safe medication or substituting the existing with safe one | ||
Always | 114 | 27 |
Never | 187 | 44.3 |
Sometimes | 121 | 28.7 |
Practice intervention related to ordering routine preconception laboratory investigation | ||
Always | 113 | 26.8 |
Never | 181 | 42.9 |
Sometimes | 128 | 30.3 |
Practice intervention related to diagnosing and management of acute or chronic preconception risk condition | ||
Always | 138 | 32.7 |
Never | 187 | 44.3 |
Sometimes | 97 | 23 |
Always | 139 | 32.9 |
Never | 181 | 42.9 |
Sometimes | 102 | 24.2 |
Practice intervention related to vaccination of clients as per the national protocol | ||
Always | 161 | 38.1 |
Never | 166 | 39.3 |
Sometimes | 95 | 22.5 |
Practice intervention related to pregnancy confirmation | ||
Always | 156 | 37 |
Never | 153 | 36.3 |
Sometimes | 113 | 26.7 |
Practice intervention related to linking client to other dept. or organization | ||
Always | 184 | 43.6 |
Never | 143 | 33.9 |
Sometimes | 95 | 22.5 |
Practice intervention related to provider-initiated HIV testing and counseling (PIHTC) | ||
Always | 171 | 40.6 |
Never | 156 | 37 |
Sometimes | 95 | 22.5 |
Factor Associated with Preconception Care Practice of Health Care Provider
From binary analysis practicing preconception care significantly associated with healthcare provider knowledge about PCC, profession (midwifery and nurse), their experience (2-5 years), educational status (both diploma and degree level) and with practice setting at p-value less than or equal to 0.05 and 95% CI (Table 4).
Table 4: Bivariate analysis of practicing preconception care
Variables | Health care providers practical status of PCC | |
Frequency | ||
Yes | No | |
PCC knowledge good knowledge | 125 | 111 |
Poor knowledge | 7 | 179 |
Participants profession | ||
Midwifery Yes | 19 | 17 |
No | 113 | 273 |
Nurse Yes | 60 | 71 |
No | 72 | 219 |
Educational status | ||
Diploma Yes | 95 | 242 |
No | 37 | 48 |
Degree | ||
Yes | 37 | 48 |
No | 95 | 242 |
Participants experience | ||
2-5 years Yes | 70 | 96 |
No | 62 | 194 |
Practice setting | ||
Health center Yes | 80 | 132 |
No | 52 | 158 |
Hospital Yes | 19 | 30 |
No | 113 | 260 |
Health post Yes | 43 | 118 |
No | 89 | 172 |
Multivariate logistic regression analysis of those independent variables with p-value less than or equal to 0.05 showed healthcare provider knowledge about PCC, being midwifery and nurse in profession, and practicing in Health center and Health post had significant association with health workers preconception care practice (Table 5).
Table 5: Multivariable logistic regression analysis preconception care
Variables | Frequency | |
Yes | No | |
PCC knowledge good knowledge | 125 | 111 |
Poor knowledge | 7 | 179 |
Participants profession | ||
Midwifery Yes | 19 | 17 |
No | 113 | 273 |
Nurse Yes | 60 | 71 |
No | 72 | 219 |
Practice setting | ||
Health center Yes | 80 | 132 |
No | 52 | 158 |
Health post Yes | 43 | 118 |
No | 89 | 172 |
Discussion
Form total 422 participants 236(55.9%) had good knowledge of Preconception care. Three hundred eighty eight (91.9%) knew who is eligible for Preconception care; three hundred forty six (81.9%) knew when to start preconception care; three hundred twenty (75.8%) knew periodontal disease is risk factor for Adverse Pregnancy Outcome; three hundred seven (72.7%) knew women with BMI less/equal 18.4 at risk for APO; three hundred thirty (78.2%) knew all women of reproductive age should take 0.4mg folic acid daily; two hundred eighty eight (67.8%) knew recommended preconception laboratory test include hgb, hct, HIV,Hbv and RPR or VDRL tests; Two hundred fifty nine (61.4%) knew women planning pregnancy should aim 30 minute of moderate exercise 5 days a week; three hundred seven (72.7%) knew women planning pregnancy should be advised to delay pregnancy until reducing drug, alcohol and tobacco use; two hundred sixty seven (63.3%) knew avoiding exposure to environmental hazard or toxins such as ionizing radiation, pesticides, lead, mercury and pets is a concern for women with established first trimester pregnancy not for couples planning pregnancy; two hundred eighty five (67.5%) knew clinician attending client with previous CS should advice the client to delay the next pregnancy for at least 18 month before next conception and one hundred twenty nine (35.3%) health care providers knew infertility screening and managements is not the concern of preconception care. With the exception of knowledge about fertility majority of the participants knew more than half of knowledge related question theoretically. The most important thing to preconception care knows infertility since other factors related to conception are raised if both couples are fertile. But less than half of the participants responded as infertility was not concern of preconception which basic and core concern of preconception.
Form total 422 participants 132(31.3%) had practiced Preconception care. Two hundred thirty-nine (56.6%) of participants always counsel on FP method; Two hundred eleven (50%) always counsel on pregnancy planning; one hundred fifty-six (37%) always counsel on regular exercise; one hundred eighty-four (43.6%) always counsel on body weight.
Two hundred thirteen (50.4%) always counsel on alcohol, tobacco and psychoactive substance use. One hundred sixty (37.9%) always counsel on multivitamin containing folic acid. One hundred thirty-five (32%) always counsel on the importance of maintaining good control of preexisting medical condition before conception. One hundred forty-nine (35.3%) always counsel on importance of screening for STI/HIV. One hundred thirty (30.8%) always counsel on the dangers of prescribed and non-prescribed medication use. One hundred forty-six (34.6%) always counsel on environmental hazard and toxin. One hundred fifty-nine (37.7%) always counsel on preventive vaccine. One hundred sixty-two (38.4%) always counsel on the importance of inviting partner for pc counseling, risk screening and mgt. One hundred fifty (35.5%) always practice intervention related to folic acid supplementation. One hundred sixty-two (38.4%) always practice intervention related to substance use cessation e.g alcohol, cigarette or other drugs. One hundred fourteen (27%) always practice intervention related to selecting safe medication or substituting the existing with safe one. One hundred thirteen (26.8%) always practice intervention related to ordering routine preconception laboratory investigation. One hundred thirty-eight (32.7%) always practice intervention related to diagnosing and managing of acute or chronic preconception risk condition. One hundred thirty-nine (32.9%) always practice intervention related to controlling existing presentational chronic disease.
One hundred sixty-one (38.1%) always practice interventions related to vaccination of clients as per the national protocol. One hundred fifty-six (37%) always practice interventions related to pregnancy confirmation. One hundred eighty-four (43.6%) always practice interventions related to linking client to other relevant dept. or organization. One hundred seventy-one (40.6%) always practice intervention related to provider-initiated HIV testing counseling. The result of this finding showed huge problem in implementing what they know theoretically about preconception care. This may arise from policy, low request from care seekers and setting in which they are working. In our country health facility has only maternity ward that provides service after conception, family planning based on request without considering it as preconception care and PMTCT aimed at preventing HIV transmission to fetus.
Practicing preconception care significantly associated with healthcare provider knowledge about PCC, being midwifery and nurse in profession, and practicing in HC and HP had significant association with preconception care practice.
Conclusion
Two hundred thirty-six (55.9%) had good knowledge of Preconception care and one hundred thirty-two (31.3%) had practiced Preconception care. Practicing preconception care significantly associated with healthcare provider knowledge about PCC, profession (midwifery and nurse), and practice setting (HC and HP) had significant association with preconception care practice.
Declarations
Recommendation
As finding of this study has shown the knowledge and practice of preconception care was low.
Regional health bureau
Should raise the knowledge and practice health care providers by providing training
Facility administration
Should arrange staff and ward for preconception care provision
Data availability
All reliable data should be offered when requested
Ethical Approval and consent of participation
Ethical clearance was obtained from the ethical committee of the department of midwifery Faculty of public health and medical science in Mettu University. The respondents were informed about the objective, the purpose, scope and expected outcome of the research of the study and informed consent was obtained from each respondent. Confidentiality of the data was kept through omitting the respondents name from the questionnaire.
Acknowledgement
We would like to pass our heartfelt thanks to Mettu university research and technology transfer directorate allowing us to undergo this study also faculty of public health and medical science department of midwifery, the student’s & others who have a role in this study.
Funding
Author received no funds.
Conflict of interest
We declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Ontario Public Health Association. (2014). Shift - Enhancing the health of Ontarians: A call to action for preconception health promotion and care. Toronto, ON.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Chandranipapongse W, Koren G. (2013). Preconception counseling for preventable risks. Canadian Family Physician. 59(7):737-739.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Salihu H, Salinas A, Mogos M. (2013). The missing link in preconception care: the role of comparative effectiveness research. Maternal and Child Health Journal. 17(5):776-782.
Publisher | Google Scholor - World Health Organization. (2013). Preconception care: maximizing the gains for maternal and child health [pamphlet]. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Global Mother Child Research [Internet]. London (UK): The Global Health Network; c2009-2014. Systematic review of preconception risks and interventions.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Singh S, Sedgh G, Hussain R. (2010). Unintended pregnancy: worldwide levels, trends, and outcomes. Studies in Family Planning. 41(4):241-250.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Wise PH. (2008). Transforming preconceptional, prenatal, and interconceptional care into a comprehensive commitment to women's health. Womens Health Issues. 18(6): S13-S18.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Alberta Perinatal Health Program. [Internet]. Edmonton (AB): Alberta Perinatal Health Program c2014. Preconception health framework.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Standards, Programs & Community Development Branch - Ministry of Health Promotion. Reproductive health guidance document. Ottawa ON: Queen’s Printer for Ontario, 71.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Archived – Summative Evaluation of the Canada Prenatal Nutrition Program 2004-2009 [Internet]. Ottawa: Public Health Agency of Canada; c2014. Key findings.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Okun N, Sierra S. (2014). Pregnancy outcomes after assisted human reproduction. Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada, 302;65-83.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Bialystok L, Poole N, Greaves L. (2013). Preconception care: call for national guidelines. Can Fam Physician, 59(10):1037-1039.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Filner LB, Zolna MR. Unintended pregnancy in the United States: incidence and disparities, 2006. Contraception, 84(5):478-485.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Moos MK, Dunlop AL, Jack BW, Nelson L, Coonrod DV, Long R, et al. Healthier women, healthier reproductive outcomes: recommendations for the routine care of all women of reproductive age. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, 6(2): S280-S289.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Yi Y, Lindermann M, Coligs A, Snowball C. (2011). Economic burden of neural tube defects and impact of prevention with folic acid: a literature review. Eur J Pediatr, 170(11);1391-1400.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Canadian Public Health Association. Leading together: Canada takes action on HIV/AIDS (2005-2010). Ottawa (ON): Canadian HIV/AIDS Information Centre, 8.
Publisher | Google Scholor - Kingston-Riechers J. (2011). The economic cost of HIV/AIDS in Canada. Ottawa, ON: Canadian AIDS Society, 17.
Publisher | Google Scholor - To promote and protect the health of canadians through leadership, partnership, innovation and action in public health. Public health agency of canada
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconceptional care: a systematic review of the currentsituation and recommendations for the future
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconception Care:Practice and Policy Implications for Nurses
Publisher | Google Scholor - Healthcare providers’ views on the delivery of preconception care in a local community setting in the Netherlands
Publisher | Google Scholor - The Future of Preconception Care a Clinical Perspective
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconception Health Attitudes and Behaviours ofWomen: A Qualitative Investigation
Publisher | Google Scholor - Effectiveness of general preconception care accompanied by a recruitment approach: protocol of a communitybased cohort study (the Healthy Pregnancy 4 All study)
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconceptional care: a systematic review of the currentsituation and recommendations for the future
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconception Care in International SettingsSheree L. Boulet · Christopher Parker · Hani Atrash
Publisher | Google Scholor - Preconceptional care: a systematic review of the currentsituation and recommendations for the future
Publisher | Google Scholor - A systematic review of women’s and healthprofessional’s attitudes and experience of preconception care service delivery
Publisher | Google Scholor